Jennifer M. Hayden is an attorney with Pettit Law Group S.C. and has been practicing law for 19 years. She concentrates her practice on Landlord-Tenant law and focuses on finding practical solutions for landlords and property management companies throughout the state of Wisconsin regarding both residential and commercial properties.
Jennifer has handled numerous contested eviction cases as well as litigation related to Fair Housing, building code orders, and the defense of alleged Wisconsin Administrative Code – ATCP 134 violations. She regularly consults with landlords and property management companies to respond to current issues as well as to develop “best practices.”
Jennifer edited Tristan Pettit’s The Landlord’s Companion: A Comprehensive Handbook of Residential Landlord-Tenant Law in Wisconsin, which was published in 2024, she guest blogs on Tristan’s Landlord-Tenant Law Blog (www.LandlordTenantLawBlog.com), she contributed to the State Bar of Wisconsin’s Pinnacle publication entitled Wisconsin Landlord & Tenant Manual (2nd ed.), and she has co-authored an article for the Wisconsin Lawyer on Act 317. She is a member of the Waukesha Area Apartment Association and obtained an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell in 2013.
Jennifer is licensed to practice law in the State of Wisconsin, the Eastern and Western Districts of Wisconsin Federal Courts, as well as the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals.
Paralegals
Jesse Shefchik
jshefchik@pettit-law.com
Samantha Liedtke
sliedtke@pettit-law.com
Justin Pond
jpond@pettit-law.com
Admissions
State of Wisconsin
U.S. District Court, Eastern and Western Districts of Wisconsin
U.S. Court of Appeals, 7th Circuit
Legal Recognition
Martindale-Hubbell — AV Preeminent (2013 – present)
Education
J.D.: Marquette University
B.A.: Marquette University
Professional + Civic Activities
State Bar of Wisconsin
Milwaukee Bar Association
Association of Women Lawyers, Former Member and Former Assistant Director of Membership
Waukesha County Bar Association, Former Member and Former Chair of the Young Lawyers Division
Waukesha Landlord Association (WLA)
Client Reviews
-
![]()
Nathan Schultz
I have used this law firm several times over the past 10 years as a landlord, and I must say that my experience has been nothing short of outstanding. They get right to the point and their team demonstrates unparalleled professionalism and expertise.
The attorneys I've worked with at this firm were not only knowledgeable about landlord-tenant laws but also exhibited a deep understanding of the challenges landlords face in today's dynamic real estate environment. They provided clear and concise guidance that has been valuable as I navigate through complex legal issues.
What truly sets them apart is their commitment to client communication. I always feel well-informed and supported and they are quick to respond, even on small matters. The team promptly addresses my concerns and patiently explains legal jargon when needed. This level of transparency and accessibility makes them my “go-to.”
I highly recommend them to any landlord seeking top-notch legal representation. Their expertise, professionalism, and client-centric approach make them a standout choice for navigating the complexities of landlord-tenant law. I am truly grateful for their excellent service and for being a reliable partner in safeguarding my interests as a landlord.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Google
-
![]()
Patrick Graham
Tristan, Jen and the staff at Petrie Pettit have been a tremendous resource for our property management firm for over a decade. In addition to skillfully handling all litigation, we regularly lean on their expertise for developing our own policies, procedures and staff training plans.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Google
-
![]()
Derek Weiler
I have utilized the services of Petrie + Pettit for over 10 years, and I have never been dissatisfied with this firm. As I continue to develop my career, and expand my network of relationships with other real estate management professionals, I will vigorously recommend this firm. Your positive outcome may be slow in coming at times, but that is because these brilliant legal minds are carefully crafting a strategy that give the best chance of a successful outcome. Atty Tristan Pettit, Atty Jennifer Hayden, Atty David McClurg, and Atty Gary Koch are top notch professionals. The support staff for each of these experienced attorneys is responsive and courteous.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Google
-
![]()
Susan Sellin
Everyone at Petrie & Pettit is always helpful, professional and thorough. We rely on them for rental and eviction advice for our large apartment complex. We have never had a problem with their services.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Google
-
![]()
Abby Kaye Paul
This firm is the truly the best. Tristan, Jen and Jesse have been part of our success. They are never more than 1 email away with an answer and have resolved the standard and most unique of situations. More than helpful, kind, and always know we are guided in the right direction.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Google
-
![]()
Michele Hood
I have worked with the team at Petrie & Pettit for years. They are very knowledgeable, quick to respond in a timely manner and instill confidence that your best interests are met. I really enjoy working with Jennifer Hayden and Samantha Liedtke on our property management concerns!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Google
Authorship
Wisconsin Landlord & Tenant Manual
At some point in their lives, most Wisconsinites have been renters and leased an apartment, duplex, townhome, or single-family home. Wisconsin Landlord & Tenant Manual provides attorneys, landlords, and tenants with a solid guide to residential landlord-tenant law. This highly accessible guide walks readers through the life cycle of a tenancy from the perspectives of both landlords and tenants.